Credit risk modelling is a crucial component of banking and lending operations. As financial institutions aim to understand and quantify credit risk, they rely on sophisticated models to help them make smarter lending decisions. 

To put it simply, lenders need credit risk models to manage credit risk. Lending money to someone with a poor risk profile can lead to financial loss, affecting your lending business's bottom line or your personal finances.

This is where credit risk modelling comes into play. It is a method that uses statistical techniques to evaluate a borrower's creditworthiness and estimate the likelihood of them defaulting on their payments.

These models can  range from simple credit scoring models to complex models that consider multiple factors, including:

• Financial statements

• Credit bureau data

• Alternate data

Factors Affecting Credit Risk Modelling

For lenders to minimise credit risk, credit risk forecasting needs to be more precise. Here are some factors to consider: 

Probability of default (POD) 

POD is the likelihood that a borrower will fail to pay their loan obligations, and lenders use it to assess the level of risk that comes with loaning money.

For individual borrowers, the POD is typically based on two primary factors:

1. Credit score 

2. Debt-to-income ratio

The former shows a borrower's creditworthiness and their history of paying off loans, while the latter shows the proportion of their income dedicated to paying previous debts. Combined, these factors paint a picture of a borrower's financial stability and indicate if they're likely to default on their loan.

When dealing with corporate borrowers, the POD is based on their credit rating, which is obtained from credit rating agencies. These agencies assess the borrower's creditworthiness and assign a credit score that reflects their ability to pay off their debts. If a potential borrower has a low probability of default, the lender can offer them a low-interest rate and low or no down payment on the loan. However, to mitigate the risk of default, the lender typically takes security in the form of collateral against the loan. 

Loss given default (LGD) 

LGD refers to the amount of money a lender is likely to lose if a borrower defaults on a loan, helping them predict and manage their risk exposure. LGD accounts for:

• The value of the collateral

• The type of loan

• The legal framework in which the lender operates

It helps lenders with credit risk management and make informed decisions about loan pricing and underwriting. 

Exposure at default (EAD)

EAD refers to the amount of possible loss a lender is exposed to at any point in time, allowing them to better manage their risk. It considers factors including:

• The outstanding principal balance,

• Accrued interest, and

• Any fees or penalties associated with the loan

Data and Variables Used in Credit Risk Modelling

Credit risk modelling relies on various data sources and variables to determine a borrower's creditworthiness. While it is important to ensure the accuracy and completeness of the data used, it is equally crucial to select the most relevant data sources and variables. 

Types of data used in credit risk modelling:

1. Financial Statements : When it comes to B2B lending, lenders will consider the financial statements of borrowing institutions in credit risk modelling. Models like  Altman Z score and Moody's Risk Calc account for well-known financial ratios that can be useful in determining credit risk, such as debt-to-equity ratio, current ratio, and interest coverage.

2. Credit Bureau Data : Credit bureau data is a repository of information on the credit history of individuals and companies. It is used to determine a borrower's creditworthiness, provide insights into their credit behaviour such as their credit score, payment history, credit utilisation, and outstanding debts.

3. Alternate Data : Alternate data is data drawn from unconventional sources that supplements financial data and bureau scores in digital lending. This includes social media activity, online purchasing behaviour, and other non-financial data points.

Alternate data is becoming increasingly popular in credit risk modelling. It allows lenders to understand better the financial behaviours of new-to-credit borrowers who may not have a long credit history.

Importance of data quality and selection in credit risk modelling

Data quality plays a crucial role in credit risk modelling, as it directly impacts risk management and regulatory compliance in financial services. Ensuring data accuracy, integrity, and validity is essential for minimising risks and maintaining credibility. In many cases, data quality dimensions are divided as per the following:

1. Intrinsic Data Quality

Intrinsic data quality refers to the inherent properties of the data, such as accuracy, objectivity, and reputation. Accuracy is vital in credit risk modelling, as inaccurate data can lead to incorrect risk assessments and poor decision-making. Objectivity ensures that data is unbiased and free from personal opinions or preferences. Reputation refers to the trustworthiness of the data source, which is essential for maintaining credibility in the financial services industry

2. Contextual Data Quality

Contextual data quality focuses on the relevance and timeliness of the data in relation to the specific task at hand. In credit risk modelling, it is crucial to have up-to-date and relevant data to make accurate risk assessments. For example, customer data can drift and lose integrity over time, leading to inaccurate risk evaluations

3. Representational Data Quality

Representational data quality deals with the format, structure, and presentation of the data. In credit risk modelling, data should be presented in a clear and understandable manner to facilitate effective decision-making. This includes ensuring that data is consistent, coherent, and easily interpretable by analysts and decision-makers

4. Accessibility Data Quality

Accessibility data quality refers to the ease with which data can be obtained, used, and shared. In credit risk modelling, it is essential to have efficient access to relevant data sources to enable timely and accurate risk assessments. This includes ensuring that data is available, secure, and easily retrievable when needed.

Techniques Used in Credit Risk Modelling

The choice of technique depends on the dataset's nature and the borrower's risk profile. Common techniques are : 

1. Linear and Logistic Regression Analysis

These are the most commonly used statistical techniques in credit risk modelling. These techniques help to identify the relationship between various credit risk factors and the likelihood of default.

Linear regression analysis is used to model continuous target variables, while logistic regression analysis is used to model binary target variables.

For instance, a linear regression model can help predict the probability of default based on a borrower's credit score, income, and debt-to-income ratio. The model outputs a probability score, which indicates the likelihood of default. The higher the score, the more likely the borrower is to default.

2. XGBoost, LGBM, Random Forests

Decision tree-based techniques, such as XGBoost, LGBM, and Random Forests, are also widely used in credit risk modelling. These techniques are particularly useful in handling high-dimensional datasets and capturing non-linear relationships between variables.

Random Forests, for instance, uses an ensemble of decision trees to generate multiple predictions and combines them to obtain a more accurate prediction.

XGBoost and LGBM are gradient-boosting techniques that optimise the model's parameters by minimising the error rate in each iteration.

3. Neural Networks

Neural networks are deep learning models that are gaining popularity in credit risk modelling. These models can capture complex patterns in large datasets and are particularly useful in predicting default risk for high-risk borrowers.

These work by simulating the behaviour of neurons in the human brain. The network consists of layers of interconnected nodes that learn to recognize patterns in the input data. The output layer produces a probability score that indicates the likelihood of default.

Challenges and Limitations of Credit Risk Modelling

From dynamic regulatory requirements to evolving customer behaviours, the challenges facing credit risk professionals have never been greater. Let’s see the top few:

1. Data availability and quality:

Credit risk models rely on a wide range of data sources to accurately assess the risk of potential borrowers. These data sources include financial statements, credit bureau data, and alternate data.

However, there are often limitations to the availability and quality of these data sources, which can impact the accuracy of the model's predictions.

For example, during the COVID-19 pandemic, many small businesses were forced to close or scale back operations. This made it difficult for lenders to obtain up-to-date financial statements and other data on these businesses, making it harder to assess their credit risk accurately. As a result, many lenders had to rely on assumptions and estimates when making lending decisions, which increased the risk of defaults.

2. Assumptions and simplifications made in modelling:

Credit risk models are based on a series of assumptions and simplifications about the factors influencing a borrower's credit risk. These assumptions and simplifications can be helpful for streamlining the modelling process, but they can also limit the accuracy of the model's predictions.

For example, many credit risk models use simplified assumptions about the relationship between a borrower's credit score and risk. However, research has shown that the relationship between credit score and credit risk is not always straightforward and can vary depending on other factors. This means that credit risk models that rely too heavily on credit score data may not accurately reflect a borrower's true risk.

3. Model validation and backtesting:

Credit risk models need to be regularly validated and backtested to ensure they accurately predict credit risk. However, this can be challenging in practice, particularly when the models are based on complex credit risk algorithms or data sources.

4. Regulatory requirements:

Regulatory requirements can also create challenges and limitations for credit risk modelling. Regulators may require lenders to use specific data or models when assessing credit risk, limiting their ability to innovate or adapt to changing market conditions.

Applications of Credit Risk Modelling

Credit risk assessment for consumer and commercial lending Credit risk models are used to evaluate the creditworthiness of individuals and businesses seeking loans using factors such as credit history, income, debt-to-income ratio, and other financial indicators. 

Portfolio risk management By analysing the creditworthiness of individual borrowers and aggregating the results, credit risk models are used to measure and manage risk in a lender's loan portfolio. 

Regulatory compliance (e.g. Basel III) Credit risk modelling is essential for meeting regulatory requirements for banks and other financial institutions. Basel III, a set of international banking regulations, requires banks to maintain a certain level of capital based on their credit risk exposure.

Stress testing and scenario analysis Credit risk models are used to simulate a range of scenarios to test the resilience of a lender's loan portfolio. Stress tests help lenders identify potential losses under adverse economic conditions, such as a recession or financial crisis.

Conclusion

Credit risk modelling is essential for lending institutions to manage their portfolio risk more efficiently. This sophisticated analytical technique considers countless factors that impact borrowers' creditworthiness, such as income, credit score, history, and financial behaviour. Banks and lenders can easily identify risky investments through credit risk modelling, hence reducing potential losses, and increasing their profits.

Furthermore, credit risk models can help financial institutions comply with regulatory requirements, such as Basel II and III, which mandate financial institutions to maintain adequate capital reserves. Banks that fail to meet these requirements could face hefty fines and the risk of losing their banking licences.

If you're looking to improve your credit risk modelling and stay ahead of potential risks, FinBox's DeviceConnect is the solution you've been searching for.

FinBox’s DeviceConnect utilises real-time data from devices to provide continuous updates on credit risk changes, eliminating delays in identifying potential issues. Unlike traditional models that rely solely on traditional data, DeviceConnect considers alternate data, providing a more comprehensive understanding of credit risk. 

Plus, with transparency at the forefront of our approach, our platform offers clear insights into how our models arrive at their conclusions. 

Upgrade your credit risk modelling with FinBox's DeviceConnect and take control of your credit risk assessment today. 

Book a demo today!